|
Why You Shouldn’t Pit Faculty Feedback Against Professional Admissions Editing
It happens all the time: A student sends me a draft they’ve revised with a professor’s help. Then they say: “I’m not sure whose advice to follow… you or them.” But here’s the truth: Your professor and your editor bring very different strengths to the table. And you don’t need to choose one over the other; you just need to understand what each of us is actually here to do. Let’s break it down. What Your Professor Offers: Subject Knowledge + General Support If you’ve been lucky enough to work with a professor who’s reading your statement, that’s a gift. Truly. They know your field. They know your work ethic. And they probably want to help, especially if they’re writing you a letter of recommendation. But here’s the thing, professors are often:
And because they’re not in admissions, they may not know what current committees actually look for, or how tightly written, purpose-driven, and accessible your essay needs to be. What Your Editor Offers: Structure, Strategy, and Admissions-Savvy Polish This is where I come in. As an admissions editor, my job isn’t just to check your grammar. It’s to:
I’ve read hundreds of successful essays. I know what lands. I know when a statement is strong but flat. And I know how to take a thoughtful draft and elevate it to the level where it stands out in a sea of sameness. The Best Approach: Use Both (In the Right Order) If your professor is willing to read a draft, amazing. They can:
But send your essay to your editor last. That’s when the real sharpening happens: cutting through the fluff, reshaping the arc, and making sure your message reads loud and clear to people who don’t know you. Think of it like this:
What to Do When Feedback Conflicts It’s totally normal for professors to suggest adding something you’ve already cut for length, or for me to suggest cutting something they told you to include. So, what do you do?
When in doubt, talk it through. I love helping clients weigh trade-offs. That’s part of the job. Final Thought Your professor isn’t wrong. Your editor isn’t overstepping. You’re not stuck between two opinions; you’re building a team. So yes, take the support. Get feedback early from someone who knows you. And when you’re ready to make it shine? That’s where I come in. Want help bringing your final draft across the finish line? I work with applicants who’ve done the hard thinking; now they need the structure, clarity, and polish to make their statement land with real impact. Contact me at [email protected]
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |
Elizabeth DoyleAdmissions editor. PhD scholar. 10+ years on selection committees. I work with individuals and organizations worldwide to elevate their writing - no hand-holding, just results. Archives
January 2026
Categories |
RSS Feed